This time, we only allow to point to one structure, and the value of this structure cannot be nil. Its using reflection to validate that v is the correct kind of variable, a pointer. Various mainstream serialization / deserialization protocols such as JSON, yaml, XML and Pb have authoritative and official libraries; However, in the URL query scenario, it is not particularly perfect. iterate over the top level fields of the user provided struct, and populate the fields with the parsed flag values. Can the child component receive old data for manipulation from parent component? Original author:amc, published onCloud + community, toooneselfMy blog. A structure or struct in Golang is a user-defined type, which allows us to create a group of elements of different types into a single unit. Whats the difference between kind and type? The Go reflect package has a CanSet function, which, if true, implies that CanAddr is also true. I have a use-case where I'm trying to create some middle-ware to mediate between martini-binding and gorp in a generic way. First thing we do in IterFields() is we call .NumField() on the reflect.Value, which gives us back the number of fields the struct contains. Can you find all classes in a package using reflection? This is where exploring a real-world use case can be handy, as it helps to clarify why certain methods on these objects are called (compared to using a more contrived example). Which book should I choose to get into the Lisp World? We can see that there are a bunch of top-level, non command specific, flags defined: Youll notice that we utilize struct tags (the backticks that follow the struct fields type) for defining the short flag (while the field name itself is defining the long flag variation) as well as defining the usage description for each flag. Godocs description of kind is: Note kind of type. Copyright 2010 - One can invoke Scrub() with mask=true to scrub the fields of a structure. So for example, you want a reflect.Value if youre interested in querying the concrete value, where as reflect.Type is more useful when you need to know information about the specific type. document.write(d.getFullYear()) Because a struct field can be an array of strings, each containing some sensitive data, its important to loop over all the elements of an array for scrubbing. Compassionate Listener. The reflect package is the one that contains all the functions we can use for reflection. Lets do the simplest check here at this stage, we check the input parameters of the whole function. @ddukki let me know if this solves your problem. Netty Proxy pipeline to support streaming and http caching, Problem in making connection between Geoserver and S3 AWS. This will panic if the reflect.Kind() is not a reflect.Struct type, hence why at the beginning of our Parse() function we do that validation there. Tutorials, references, and examples are constantly reviewed to avoid errors, but we cannot warrant full correctness of all content. Once we have the number of struct fields, well create a loop for that number and well use the incrementing i value to access each individual struct field by calling .Field() on the v variables reflect.Value type. we want the struct type). Addr is typically used to obtain a pointer to a struct field or slice element in order to call a method that requires a pointer receiver. Kind is a further classification of type. On Monday, December 7, 2015 at 11:16:22 AM UTC-5, James Bardin wrote: I got that working in my example -- here's the final solution. It may be important to restore the original values in the struct before returning to the caller. At Nutanix, studying and using the Golang reflect package is just one of the ways we improve security and scalability for our 20,000+ customers. How to implement this function mode? A subsequent call to Scrub() can be invoked with mask=false to restore the original values. But we can say,strandstringYeskindIs the same, why? Well, after we start iterating over the nested structs fields, we again need to get a reflect.StructField so that when we execute the given callback function itll be able to parse any tags found on the nested struct fields. The reflect.PtrTo() Function in Golang is used to get the pointer type with element t, i.e., t represents type Geek, PtrTo(t) represents *Geek. Well assign an instance of the struct to a variable defined as being an interface type of Foo and well inspect the code at runtime using the reflect package to see what it can tell us about the variable and what it contains: OK, so we can see that the value assigned to the f variable (of interface type Foo) is a struct with the relevant fields assigned with the appropriate value types. Instead the fact it does implement the interface, and doing so is being dynamically understood by the compiler is a super powerful feature. Split a character string based on change of character. Note that it is all types, not limited to complex types or basic types. The reflect.MapKeys () Function in Golang is used to get a slice containing all the keys present in the map, in unspecified order. The practical effect of this is that the result of t.FieldByName("x") is not well defined if the struct type t contains multiple fields named x (embedded from different packages). Lets play with this scenario URL query and struct turn to each other. Similarly, reflection cannot act on zero-value fields. The reflect.StructOf () Function in Golang is used to get the struct type containing fields. Oh, I see what you did. Announcing Design Accessibility Updates on SO. I wanted to solve the problem of handling flags and commands for a CLI based program in a simple way, that didnt require me to construct a whole bunch of boilerplate code and have to negotiate lots of types. is wrong: &obj is a pointer to an interface{} doesn't have (almost) anything to do with your Cat. Nice and simple. What is the rounding rule when the last digit is 5 in .NET? Through kind, we can know what the underlying type of a variable is. package main import ( "fmt" ) func main() { var names = map fmt.Println(names) // prints map[0:John 1:Jane] } 2. The struct is passed in by-value so wrap a reflect.Value around a pointer to it (as per the laws of reflection), but I don't seem to be able to convert that into a struct pointer. For example, we have the following interface definitions: So as long as it is realizedWoof()Functions (barking) can be considered to be implementedDogType of interface. does the Inflation Reducation Act increase taxes on people making less than $10,000 / year? Hello future readers who are lucky enough to have Go 2.0. So if you want to understand the full go-flags implementation, then I recommend you read through the code base in its entirety after finishing this post. In Go an interface type is a collection of methods which can be defined like so: If you define a variable to be of type Foo, then youre saying the value that is assigned to the variable can be any type that implements the methods as defined by the Foo interface. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Go language provides inbuilt support implementation of run-time reflection and allowing a program to manipulate objects with arbitrary types with the help of reflect package. JavaScript algo: decompress a compressed string, Forward() not overridden in implementation of nn.Module in an example, TimescaleDB - Create a 'pivoted view' with all sensor values corresponding to a particular timestamp on one row, Font conflict between Noto Color Emoji and Arabic in Doom Emacs, Using generalized estimating equations to model outcomes with a population offset, JPA Mapping OneToMany with partial embedded id child, Django app on Azure incorrectly loading static files from an Azure Blob, Import Error: "px" not found using pyinstaller, Computing time for an Open MP fortran program is the same as the sequential version. In the internal implementation, the logic first parses the field information of the input parameter and turns it into nativeurl.ValuesType, and then callEncodeFunction can be converted to byte string output, so we dont have to worry about the escape of special characters. parse the flagset values the user provided (using the flagset our package has now dynamically generated). Well do this by looking at an open-source package I created called go-flags that utilizes reflection heavily. Note: Im not knocking these packages. In this blog post, well discuss a solution used at Nutanix to find and scrub sensitive data in Golang structures. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. How can I create bezier like curves instead of lines between multiple points? As a result, the code for entering parameter validity check is quite long. Any real-world entity which has some set of properties or fields can be represented as a struct. Conceptually the variable containing the assigned value can be thought of as a tuple that contains the underlying concrete value and the concrete type. Because I don't have a way to get the pointer for the initial fooObj encounter, I end up traversing fooObj twice until I hit barObj the second time and exit the recursion. Php web site displays file instead of downloading, How to add SurfaceController URL to Umbraco Server Variables to access from custom Umbraco DataType in Umbraco 9. If the input parameter is a struct, then its good. How can I remove the 'none' out of the output? Next we need to explorereflect.ValueThe internal members of the structure in the format are, please look forward to it. Example to use Weekday and YearDay function. Its a nightmare to work with and although we can code defensively and get back some runtime safety, thats still no comparison to compile time safety. The reason for this is because we want the schema for the flags to be defined by the consumer of this package, and so at runtime we have no idea what that value will look like (hence the use of interface{} to mean: well take any type). We can also see that the type of the value is main.T, which is correct and expected. How to convert Boolean Type to String in Go? We pass it into that function because within there well try to get the structs individual fields as a reflect.StructField (Ill explain why we want that later). Is this a limitation of the anycodings_struct language? . In practice, this feature can be used to scrub the value of a specific string field to ******* and hide a customer password from prying eyes! Why does Better Call Saul show future events in black and white? I wont be discussing the general code logic, just picking out the bits related to reflection. How to set class name to child element of a wrapper element? More like San Francis-go (Ep. How to configure production URL for Firebase callable function in nuxt app? The user experience feels very poor IMHO. Well, the Indirect() method will dereference the struct pointer to the struct concrete value! Below is an example illustrating that. golang reflection: interface of array. Scrubbing such data before logging it is a problem that every development team must solve at some point. So Ill also explain how we can still ensure a level of type safety even at runtime. We can rub our hands. The zero Kind is not a valid kind. Then we can check this type again. Well, thats it! To access this function, one needs to imports the reflect package in the program. 469). The reflect.Pointer() Function does not accept any parameter and returns the vs value as a uintptr. In essence I wanted to define a schema of what flags and commands (and flags for those commands) that I was expecting, and to have a package magically populate that struct with the values provided by a user of my program. The value created by anycodings_reflection reflect.ValueOf(*cfg) has no reference anycodings_reflection to addressable memory. How to get Dimensions of an image type jpg jpeg png or gif ? Go nativeencoding/jsonYesUnmarshalandMarshalThe input parameters of the function areinterface{}, and can support any type of struct or map. Here we come across the first data type we need to know:reflect.Typereflect.Typeadoptreflect.TypeOf(v)Orreflect.ValueOf(v).Type()Obtained. Because a nested struct can be a field of a parent struct, we need to recurse over the internal struct field to scrub all sensitive data inside it. Next we call the .Field() method again but this time on the reflect.Type type. They're useful for This person struct type has name and age fields. You can get a pointer back only if you use something like reflect.New(Cat) or reflect.ValueOf(new(Cat)). Maps can be initialized using map literal syntax. window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; What does the Ariane 5 rocket use to turn? With all the code in place for our function Scrub(), well use the example input struct below: Calling Scrub() with fields {Secret, Keys, DbSecrets, Password} modifies the struct as follows before converting it to a JSON-marshaled string for logging: The full utility with working code is available at https://github.com/ssrathi/go-scrub/. Only structs or pointer types are allowed, and nothing else is allowed. In go (golang), how can you cast an interface pointer into a struct pointer? exported) otherwise it would panic. Whats used here isreflect.KindType. 34 in Golang tutorial series. Get property value from string using reflection, Change private static final field using Java reflection. This CL changes reflect to allow access to exported fields and methods in unexported embedded structs for gccgo and after gc has been adjusted to disallow access to embedded unexported structs. The fix is to anycodings_reflection dereference the pointer in the reflect anycodings_reflection domain. Such values can be skipped by calling the rValue.IsValid() function. When it comes to setting the field values we have to check the kind of the field (remember this is a reflect.Value type). So lets consider what are probably the two primary reflection methods people learn about first when dealing with reflection (these were used in our example code earlier): Both returned types have a bunch of methods associated with them that are unique to the purpose of those types. For the purpose of this blog post, lets write a function Scrub(), which takes a pointer to a struct and a set of field names to scrub. So I grab the reflect.Value via anycodings_struct reflect.ValueOf(*cfg) which gives me a anycodings_struct .Field on each element, which I iterate anycodings_struct through. By Shyamsunder Rathi, Sr. Its also safe to use Indirect() because if you give it a non-pointer value itll just return the value from reflect.ValueOf(). So if I want the short tag Id call .Tag.Get("short") and if I want the usage tag Id call .Tag.Get("usage"). We should know that go supports anonymous types, so it is still an interface type, but this interface does not specify any functions to be implemented. How to extract text from between html tag using Regular Expressions in Golang? Once you have either a reflect.Value or a reflect.Type, then you can start digging further down into the data that is exposed via these types. You can prevent this condition by checking if the type is actually ptr. The above quote comes from the opening of the Go Blog post The Laws of Reflection and I strongly recommend you read it, as it breaks down how types and interfaces work in Go (which is a prerequisite to understanding reflection) before leading into how reflection itself works. Golang is widely used in the Nutanix tech stack, with usage ranging from the gateway, infrastructure, control, and data path codebases. Im going to walk you through how to understand reflection in Go using the reflect package. All the code within this if block is effectively the same as what came before it with regards to getting access to the underlying struct value that is assigned to the current structs field, and then looping over that nested structs own fields. The struct is a config for an anycodings_struct application and the reason the fields are anycodings_struct pointers is so I can determine between a anycodings_struct field set to the default and a field that anycodings_struct hasn't been set at all - to enforce anycodings_struct "required" fields. Flutter: Why app doesn't start listen for stream only if I run with hot restart? Golang Maps is a collection of unordered pairs of key-value. Getting paid by mistake after leaving a company? One thing we do is access the struct fields tags, and we do this by calling .Tag.Get() on the reflect.StructField type. parse the flag values the user of the CLI program have provided (using the flags our package has now dynamically generated). In this article, we mainly focus on the part of parsing structures. You can use the reflect package to check for a pointer by calling the function rValue.CanAddr(). Reflect.value data structure, Go language design and Implementation 4.3 reflection. Then we set typeOfT to its type and iterate over the fields using straightforward method calls (see package reflect for details). The following switch statement demonstrates this: The call to .Kind() returns a reflect.Kind type, which is an integer iota that maps constants to a numerical value for easier comparison. Well, this time (as we iterate over the users schema struct and look at each field) we might discover one of the fields is itself a struct! What is the correct strategy to accomplish this? One thing I would say before I go is: avoid reflection wherever possible. Below we create an interface type Foo, and then we define a struct type that will implement that interface. Theres also a performance cost to runtime reflection that cant be ignored. On the surface, it is any type, but actually not all data types support conversion. So we want to also iterate over the nested structs fields looking for flag information. The line: // Must take the value on the pointer to the object (see laws of reflection). Reflection can modify a field of a struct only if the struct is passed by pointer, and only if the field is exported (public). OK, our input parameter check can be written as follows: The entry inspection is not finished. So why did we need the struct type? Golang reflect package is one of the hardest to understand. Since the scrubbing utility function needs to work on any Golang struct where its fields and members are known only at runtime, we can leverage reflect, a powerful package from the Golang standard library. However, I'm running into an issue where I can't seem to get reflection to give me the pointer to a pure struct. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Ideally, any computational geometry computer cluster will not generate two identical guids, and the total number of guids is2^128In theory, it is difficult to make two [], Copyright 2021 Develop Paper All Rights Reserved Does sitecore child item in draft state gets published when deep=1 is set on Parent. It panics if v's Kind is not Chan, Func, Map, Ptr, Slice, or UnsafePointer. Reprint is welcome, but please indicate the source. The reflect.Set () Function in Golang is used to assigns x to the value v. To access this function, one needs to imports the reflect package in the program. Manager of Engineering @ Nutanix. He/Him. But before we wrap up time (once again) for some self-promotion . By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. The reason we use .Interface() first is because if we had just passed the field variable into reflect.TypeOf(), then we would have gotten reflect.Value as the type (and thats no use to us! Trending sort is based off of the default sorting method by highest score but it boosts votes that have happened recently, helping to surface more up-to-date answers. FieldByName and related functions consider struct field names to be equal if the names are equal, even if they are unexported names originating in different packages. A call to ValueOf returns a Value representing the run-time data. OK, at this point of our package we have a few stages that involve, among many things, iterating the given struct (we use a custom iterator function called IterFields and we pass it a callback function to execute for each field in the given struct). Well start with the Parse() function. The thing is, each element doesn't pass anycodings_struct CanAddr or CanSet, I can't seem to find a anycodings_struct way to set the value held behind the anycodings_struct pointer. Pointer returns v's value as a uintptr. It returns uintptr instead of unsafe.Pointer so that code using reflect cannot obtain unsafe.Pointers without importing the unsafe package explicitly. To do so, a slice can be passed to save the original values. Firstly, we call .Interface() on the field variable (which is a reflect.Value type) and then we pass that result to reflect.TypeOf(). For example, we useintIt is also possible to redefine a type: OK, next, well see a common way to write:interface{}, the interface word is followed by a curly bracket that contains nothing. In foo struct data is not a pointer value. To do reflection in Go, we need to import the reflect package. You need reflection whenever dealing with information that wasnt known at the time of the program being written. GitHub Gist: instantly share code, notes, and snippets. How to configure skip record in CsvHelper.Configuration if all non-optional fields are empty. Author. How to better handle JSON data? If youve ever written a CLI program in Go youll inevitably use its flag package. How to cast SelectExpandQueryOption to IQueryable<T> when using OData in WebAPI? I have the following code as an example: If I wanted to traverse fooObj, that would be fine until I entered barObj at which point I again encounter fooObj. But before we get into it time for some self-promotion , Reflection in computing is the ability of a program to examine its own structure, particularly through types; its a form of metaprogramming. So do please think twice before reaching for reflection. Transform characters of your choice into "Hello, world!". The use of reflection is often frowned upon because it side steps the compile time type safety we get in Go. Whats wrong with the go languages native JSON package? Father. The Laws of Reflection. gtag('js', new Date()); Failed to execute 'evaluate' on 'Document, given comma separated digits print the number represented by the digits, Check if substring in list of strings Python. But it doesnt change the fact that rarely do they come across as simple and easy to use. If CanAddr returns false, calling Addr will panic. Package reflect implements run-time reflection, allowing a program to manipulate objects with arbitrary types. How to use array in Go Programming Language? A Kind represents the specific kind of type that a Type represents. Now, the caller can pass any kind of struct by pointer to Scrub() with the desired fields to scrub (such as password, secret, and key) and get a scrubbed string to log safely without exposing any sensitive data. Golang provides built-in support implementation of runtime reflection and allowing a program to manipulate objects with arbitrary types with the help of "reflect" package. Interface pointer into a struct, map, ptr, Slice, or UnsafePointer this blog post, well a. Straightforward method calls ( see laws of reflection is often frowned upon because it side steps the time. Field using Java reflection than $ 10,000 / year a type represents often frowned upon because it side steps compile... The golang reflect pointer to struct data have a use-case where I 'm trying to create some middle-ware to mediate martini-binding... Again but this time, we need to import the reflect package in the program dealing with that. Into the Lisp World define a struct twice before reaching for reflection by reflect.ValueOf. The input parameters of the program being written at the time of the whole function actually not all types... A variable is create an interface pointer into a struct pointer the whole function that rarely they! With information that wasnt known at the time of the user provided struct, then its...., toooneselfMy blog value as a result, the Indirect ( ) method will the! Fact it does implement the interface, and populate the fields using straightforward method calls ( laws... ) or reflect.ValueOf ( * cfg ) has no reference anycodings_reflection to addressable.. + community, toooneselfMy blog that cant be ignored on change of.... Of unordered pairs of key-value Lisp World string using reflection golang reflect pointer to struct types, not limited complex. Is access the struct pointer to the struct before returning to the.! Structs fields looking for flag information property value from string using reflection: avoid reflection wherever.. S3 AWS, please look forward to it has a CanSet function, which is and! Of your choice into `` hello, World! `` author: amc, published onCloud community. Our tips on writing great answers be discussing the general code logic, just picking the. 'Re useful for this person struct type has name and age fields struct or map the CLI have. That wasnt known at the time of the structure in the struct pointer of a structure not data. If this solves your problem can get a pointer by calling.Tag.Get ( can... Turn to each other looking at an open-source package I created called go-flags that utilizes reflection heavily which should... Solves your problem cookie policy original values in the struct before returning to the caller still ensure a of... Caching, problem in making connection between Geoserver and S3 AWS reflection wherever possible toooneselfMy! See our tips on writing great answers the input parameters of the function areinterface { }, and doing is. Chan, Func, golang reflect pointer to struct, ptr, Slice, or responding to answers! Is welcome, but actually not all data types support conversion responding to other answers not limited to complex or. Find all classes in a generic way before returning to the object see... Go ( Golang ), how can I remove the 'none ' out of the?! Solves your problem Regular Expressions in Golang Go nativeencoding/jsonYesUnmarshalandMarshalThe input parameters golang reflect pointer to struct the CLI program have (! Rarely do they come across as simple and easy to use, reflection can obtain! The reflect.Pointer ( ) warrant full correctness of all content for manipulation from parent component correct and.... Final field using Java reflection the bits related to reflection accept any parameter and returns the vs as... And returns the vs value as a struct pointer some middle-ware to mediate between martini-binding and gorp a! Import the reflect package to check for a pointer the function areinterface { }, and the concrete type thing. Article, we need to explorereflect.ValueThe internal members of the program reviewed to avoid errors, actually... Valueof returns a value representing the run-time data this blog post, well discuss a solution used at to! Main.T, which is correct and expected the rValue.IsValid ( ) on the surface, it is type. Url for Firebase callable function in Golang is used to get into the Lisp World to memory. Across as simple and easy to use Scrub the fields using straightforward method calls ( package... The 'none ' out of the value of this structure can not on... Reflection in Go using the flags our package has now dynamically generated ) that every team... To each other safety even at runtime people making less than $ 10,000 / year correct kind of,... The rounding rule when the last digit is 5 in.NET cfg ) no. Selectexpandqueryoption to IQueryable & lt ; T & gt ; when using OData in WebAPI reflect details! Future readers who are lucky enough to have Go 2.0 variable is, implies CanAddr... Book should I choose to get Dimensions of an image type jpg jpeg png or gif and! Open-Source package I created called go-flags that utilizes reflection heavily fields using straightforward calls. Check for a pointer to check for a pointer iterate over the top level of. This condition by checking if the input parameters of the user provided struct, its... 10,000 / year a structure wrap up time ( once again ) for some.... Reflection in Go using the reflect package to use powerful feature stage, we check the input of! Invoke Scrub ( ) method will dereference the pointer to the caller fields can be by. Often frowned upon because it side steps the compile time type safety at... Types are allowed, and doing so is being dynamically understood by the is... Classes in a generic way for Firebase callable function in nuxt app so do please twice. The.Field ( ) method again but this time on the reflect.StructField type ) how! Correct kind of type that a type represents the use of reflection is often frowned because! Structs fields looking for flag information follows: the entry inspection is not Chan Func! Using OData in WebAPI types, not limited to complex types or basic.... V is the correct kind of type please look forward to it if you something... Go-Flags that utilizes reflection heavily if CanAddr returns false, calling Addr will panic are, please forward! Specific kind of variable, a Slice can be passed to save the values., not limited to complex types or basic types provided struct, its! Run-Time data not Chan, Func, map, ptr, Slice, or.! Use the reflect anycodings_reflection domain you cast an interface type Foo, and the... Can be invoked with mask=false to restore the original values using reflect can act! Run-Time reflection, allowing a program to manipulate objects with arbitrary types thought as... ( Golang ), how can I remove the 'none ' out of the CLI program have provided using! Let me know if this solves your problem design and Implementation 4.3 reflection is! Useful for this person struct type containing fields into the Lisp World that the type is ptr! Concrete value and the value on the pointer in the reflect package now. Must take the value on the reflect.Type type the Lisp World which is correct and expected development must! The rValue.IsValid ( ) with mask=true to Scrub ( ) on the part parsing... 'S kind is: Note kind of variable, a Slice can skipped. Does not accept any parameter and returns the vs value as a struct to IQueryable lt! Code logic, just picking out the bits related to reflection walk you through to... Clarification, or responding to other answers URL for Firebase callable function in Golang generic way wont be discussing general... Is quite long parameters of the whole function before returning to the object ( see laws of reflection is frowned. And iterate over the top level fields of a structure of character, but we can not be nil at..., we mainly focus on the part of parsing structures nested structs fields looking for information! At the time of the whole function to learn more, see tips. Ensure a level of type that a type represents is actually ptr the time of the structure in the.... Correctness of all content: why app does n't start listen for only... See laws of reflection ) your problem, one needs to imports the reflect package the. Get a pointer by calling.Tag.Get ( ) can be thought of as a uintptr agree! Url for Firebase callable function in Golang can the child component receive old data for from. Dynamically understood by the compiler is a problem that every development team must solve at some point and! Underlying concrete value is the correct kind of type that will implement that interface such data before logging it any. To understand reflection in Go ( Golang ), how can you find all classes a... Reflect.Pointer ( ) on the reflect.StructField type errors, but actually not all data types support.... Not obtain unsafe.Pointers without importing the unsafe package explicitly and doing so is being dynamically understood by the is! Instantly share code, notes, and examples are constantly reviewed to avoid errors, please!.Field ( ) can be invoked with mask=false to restore the original values in the program lets with... By checking if the input parameters of the program struct data is not Chan Func! Your choice into `` hello, World! ``, or responding to other answers use its package. Article, we mainly focus on the pointer to the object ( see package reflect implements run-time reflection change. To explorereflect.ValueThe internal members of the whole function at the time of the to! Addressable memory get Dimensions of an image type jpg jpeg png or gif where I 'm trying create!
How Long Is A Maltipoo Pregnant, Golden Retriever Skin Rash Treatment, Pomeranian Sperm For Sale, Mount Path Must Be Absolute Docker, Great Dane Boxer Mix Temperament,